Sumo Sushi In King Street District

June 18, 2010 25 comments Open printer friendly version of this article Print Article

Every neighborhood needs a good sushi joint. There are three options within walking distance of Gastronomist Cari Sanchez Potter's in Riverside: Sushi Cafe, Sake House, and Sumo Sushi. Says Sanchez-Potter: I have yet to try Sake House, and because I had a less-than-memorable lunch at Sushi Cafe that included leathery pork katsu and a bowl of languid sashimi, I won't bother to review it. (How has this restaurant been named Best Japanese Cuisine in the Best of Jacksonville awards?) But when some sushi-loving friends came in from out at the beach, we decided to hit up Sumo Sushi near the intersection of Park & King.... Join Cari Sanchez-Potter as she explores Sumo Sushi!

A bamboo fence stretching the length of the windows prohibits sidewalk passersby from having a peak at the dining space, and I’d walked by many a time wondering what lay behind the screen. This element of secrecy heightened my curiosity, and the atmosphere confirmed my suspicions – subdued lighting, Asian décor in warm, natural tones. I especially appreciate that diners can sit at the sushi bar and that it is partitioned off from the main dining area by bamboo Roman shades – a particularly clever use of a small space. The bar is flanked by statues of the namesake sumo wrestlers who looked like they’d enjoyed a few pots of chankonabe in their day.

As soon as we were seated, one of the two waitresses who attended our table presented us with a ridiculous number of menus. I believe there were something like ten pieces of paper floating around our small table for four, not to mention the daily specials listed on a whiteboard near the entrance. We were glad the servers allowed us time to shuffle through all the options and get our bearings before asking if we had any questions and taking our orders.

I ordered a bottle of Kirin Ichiban, a Japanese rice lager that is a standard at most Japanese restaurants in the States. It’s not a beer I would buy to bring home and savor, but I have yet to find a wine that I enjoy drinking with sushi and sake makes me nauseous (drank too many cheap versions from the 7-11 down the street when I lived in Kobe - oops). And, I do like Kirin Ichiban better than Asahi or Sapporo, the other big-name offerings you’ll find on Japanese menus. It doesn’t leave you with much of an aftertaste, just cleanses the palate with a crisp, dry finish… and goes really well with salty edamame. (Image from

My sushi expert friends Jenn and Adam went all out on the rolls. From the standard sushi menu, they ordered (clockwise from top left in photo) rainbow rolls (California rolls with tuna, salmon, whitefish, and avocado on the outside); crazy rolls (shrimp tempura with smoked salmon on top and eel sauce); Boston rolls (shrimp, lettuce, and mayo); and tuna rolls. They were pleased with their choices and I was particularly impressed by the large piece of tuna in the tuna rolls – not a dinky pink speck you often get at many sushi joints.

They also chose two items from the specialty sushi menu. All the sushi we ordered from the specialty menu was served on a bed of spicy mayo and nitsume (sweet eel sauce). Typically restaurants do this to cover up the taste of less-than-fresh fish, but the quality of fish is high at Sumo Sushi. If you’re not a big fan of the spicy/sweet sauces, you’d do well to request your sushi without them. The caterpillar roll consisted of shrimp tempura with spicy salmon and avocado on top.

And, the mini me was a tempura sushi filled with crab and shrimp and topped with roe. I had never before tried tempura sushi and think it might get a laugh in Japan, but being the fried-food-loving, spicy-mayo-guzzling American I am, I really enjoyed it.

Phil ordered the bento box so he could taste a variety of offerings. It included shrimp and vegetable tempura, fried gyoza, California rolls, and tuna, salmon, and yellowtail sashimi. The bento was a belly-buster and Phil enjoyed all of the items, particularly the tempura.

In Japan, I developed a craving for noodles of all sorts – rich wintry ramen, cold summery soba, and especially fat messy slurpy udon (thick wheat-flour noodles). Most of your run-of-the-mill Japanese places leave noodles off the menu, so I was very happy to see tempura udon on the menu at Sumo. The noodles were swimming in a rich broth with mushrooms, broccoli, and squash, and the shrimp tempura was served on the side so it didn’t get soggy in the soup. In my mind, the Japanese are masters at deep frying and the delicate, airy tempura coating on the shrimp further confirmed this theory of mine. I am sure this will become my go-to takeout dish!

I also ordered the Godzilla roll, and the waitress told me it was her favorite roll on the menu and an excellent choice. Well, it certainly was a treat, as much for the taste as for the creative presentation. The lobster and spicy crab rolls were topped with unagi (barbecued eel) and shaped like a killer lizard. Cool!

I especially enjoyed the rings of octopus the sushi chef used for eyes.

As you can imagine, we were stuffed once we finished all this food and couldn’t even fathom dessert. The waitstaff presented us with complementary orange segments when they brought the bill – such a nice touch and a perfect way to end the meal.

Sumo Sushi is an excellent neighborhood sushi restaurant and is one more reason I love Riverside. The atmosphere is cozy and warm, the fish is fresh, and the presentations are thoughtful and creative… certainly a step above the average joint. I look forward to returning!

Sumo Sushi
2726 Park Street, Jacksonville, FL

Cari Sánchez-Potter is an American with a Masters degree in Gastronomy from the University of Adelaide/ Le Cordon Bleu in South Australia. She grew up in the small town of Salem, Ohio and since 2000 has lived in Argentina, Spanish Basque Country, Japan, Australia, Switzerland, Boston, and Florida. Learning about people and cultures through their foodways is her passion, and She has been fortunate to live in places with some of the best food cultures in the world. Currently eating my way through Jacksonville, Florida and the American South.

She also has a brilliant blog which you can follow here: