Friday, November 20, 2009
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
 

Forgotten Proposals: The Jacksonville Quay

"The creation of the quayage would greatly improve the appearance of the waterfront in that area and would enhance the value of the adjoining property." Florida Times-Union - 1929

Published August 7, 2009 in History     Digg Digg   Share this article on Facebook Share on Facebook   twitterTweet this!

feature

Fifty-Eight years before the grand opening of the Jacksonville Landing, a similar themed public space was proposed for the Northbank riverfront.  The Jacksonville Quay was proposed by George W. Simons, Jr., a young city planner, in 1929.


What is a Quay?

Quote
A quay (UK: /ˈkiː/, US: /ˈkeɪ, ˈkweɪ/) is a wharf or bank where ships and other vessels are loaded. A quay may be constructed parallel or perpendicular to the bank of a waterway. In the United Kingdom and Commonwealth nations, the word is commonly used, while Americans typically use "wharf." Similar words are found in many European languages. In French, it is spelled quai as in Quai d'Orsay, the home of the French foreign ministry headquarters.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quay


What was the Jacksonville Quay?


This Ocean Street fish market would have been in the center of Simons' proposed Jacksonville Quay.


Quote
"Jacksonville commands an immediate trading area of at least 17 counties.  Why shouldn't the [back country] contribute a greater share of the food supply of Jacksonville?"
George W. Simons, Jr - 1929

The quay would have been a public owned riverfront market.  It would have been a centralized place where goods from at least 17 surrounding counties would have been traded and sold to the public.  


Centralized Location



The quay would have taken up three blocks of the Northbank riverfront between Main and Market Streets.  Simons believed this site was ideal because it had road, rail, water access and it was central to the residents of Duval County.


Today, this site is occupied by the Hyatt and the Landing's parking lot.



Redevelopment or Economic Engine?


Open since 1907, Seattle's Pike Place Market has become one of the city's most popular tourist destinations.  One can only wonder if the Jacksonville Quay would have enjoyed the same success.


Today downtown is known for being a place in need of redevelopment. However, 80 years ago, downtown was as vibrant as it would ever get.  Instead of being a redevelopment idea, Simons viewed the establishment of the quay as an additional economic engine for a region still recovering from the bust of the Florida Boom.


What ended up happening?

Nothing. Like many great ideas throughout time, the Quay never made it off the drawing board. Nevertheless, even today, there are those that believe a full blown public market would be a great addition to the urban waterfront.

Article by Ennis Davis

Source: Landing Idea first emerged back in 1929 by Bill Foley
Florida Times-Union 08/31/94 (Jacksonville Public Library Special Collections Department)




Share this article   digg   facebook   twitter   delicious   reddit   myspace   technorati   google   newsvine  



Metro Jacksonville on Facebook

Must Read from around the web


Jobless rates for Jacksonville remains high in October jacksonville.com - Jacksonville's unemployment rate fell slightly from 10.8 percent in September to 10.7 percent in October, the Florida Agency for Workforce Innovation reported today. But the jobless rate in the Jacksonville…

Is A Wild Card Enough? urbanjacksonville.info - Despite the balmy temperature at kick-off, the Jaguars' Week 10 game against the New York Jets definitely had the feel of December football.

Touchdown Jacksonville has big plans for Jaguars' Dec. 17 game jacksonville.com - Since the new Touchdown Jacksonville was announced Nov. 4, the group of Jacksonville businesspeople have begun work to spur Jaguars ticket sales.

Florida lawmakers weigh end of stimulus money jacksonville.com - As lawmakers grapple with a shortfall for the coming fiscal year that could total as much as $2.7 billion, there's another financial headache looming on the horizon.

Saft Confirms Location for Lithium-Ion Battery Factory in Jacksonville, Florida pr-canada.net - Following receipt of a $95 million grant from the U.S. Department of Energy under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act and successful negotiations between Saft, the state of Florida, and…

Stimulus, SunRail at forefront of TPO jaxdailyrecord.com - For board members of the North Florida Transportation Planning Organization, discussion surrounding a second helping of stimulus dollars isn't quite yet complete.

Duval Jail population is up despite fewer arrests jacksonville.com - Official explanations for that paradox range from too much bail to too few plea bargains, but the bottom line is the jail population is 24 percent over its rated capacity…

Daniels calls for change to Jacksonville council term limits jacksonville.com - Lad Daniels said it wasn't until the end of his first four-year term on the Jacksonville City Council that he finally hit his stride. By then, though, he was on…

New senator: McCain backs Mayport carrier jacksonville.bizjournals.com - Sen. John McCain is pushing for Jacksonville to get an aircraft carrier at Naval Station Mayport, Florida Sen. George LeMieux told Jacksonville business leaders Friday.

Times-Union parent turns a profit in 3Q jacksonville.bizjournals.com - Morris Publishing Group LLC pulled out of multimillion-dollar net losses in the first half of 2009 to a net income of $711,000 in the third quarter.




Follow us on the web!


Facebook Twitter Youtube Delicious Flickr RSS

» 19 Comments

zoo

August 07, 2009, 06:38:16 AM

Would love it if there was a central fish market in Jax. I've missed the ones I've frequented in other metros.

Gonzo

August 07, 2009, 07:41:24 AM

For a city which calls itself "The River City by the Sea" we a woefully inept in capitalizing on either. When you look at examples such as the Pike Place Market or Fisherman's Wharf you have to wonder why we are still missing the proverbial boat? Both of those markets are HUGE tourist draws and economic boons to their respective cities.

The recent addition and popularity of the Riverside Arts Market should be sending a very clear mesage to the city planners -- build it and they wil come!

sheclown

August 07, 2009, 07:57:14 AM

much better idea than sprinklers popping out of concrete...this is an investment that could pay for itself.

Overstreet

August 07, 2009, 09:13:11 AM

Maybe a better point with the Riverside Arts Market is you don't have to build a big expensive building to have a market that people will come to.

A central fish market might be interesting, but I have a fish market less than a mile from my house (excluding the grocery stores). To get to the central retail fish market I'd have to travel twelve miles and pass two other fish markets to get there.  Obviously I'm not the target market for that central fish market.  You need people living nearby.
Then again I’d drive thirty miles to put the boat in and maybe catch a fish. But that is a whole other discussion.

Deuce

August 07, 2009, 09:30:47 AM

Quote
Obviously I'm not the target market for that central fish market.

True dat. Problem is the city and developers think they need more people centrally to add things like this, but there is enough to launch anything as long as there's just one. Once you've got it, others will settle centrally as there's now more places to shop at, visit, etc.

I don't know if the Potomac waterfront seafood market in D.C. counts as a quay but it was totally awesome. It's not just a place to shop but also a destination.

BridgeTroll

August 07, 2009, 09:37:02 AM

I love fish markets and the idea of a Quay... I do wonder what fresh fish harvested locally would be sold in quantity and quality at a Jacksonville Quay.  The local shrimping industry barely exists anymore... seems many want to completely curtail Red Snapper harvests.

Overstreet

August 07, 2009, 09:47:23 AM

You sound like the city never did any river front development to bring people downtown.  This discounts the Landing, TUPAC, Riverwalk, River City Brewing Co. and other venues.

Here’s a link to the Soulard Farmers Market in St Louis.  Not the fisherman’s dock of San Francisco y’all seem to be talking about but a long term going concern. In the history section you’ll see that most all the improvements were by private concerns that were later taken over or purchased by the city.  The land was given to the city. Most of the buildings were developed by the farmers or developers and later sold to the city.  One thing that makes this area work is parking. The locals that live there still drive to the market.  We often went there but really did most of our shopping at Schnucks grocery stores.

http://www.soulardmarket.com/soulard_farmers_market_007.htm

Maybe it is not the City of Jacksonville, but private individuals that need to get it going and maybe not on the waterfront.

Jason

August 07, 2009, 09:51:26 AM

Could a fish market be incorporated into RAM?

copperfiend

August 07, 2009, 09:59:30 AM

We should make a book of everything that was destroyed, torn down or never built downtown. I would call it ''The Way We Weren't''.

Doctor_K

August 07, 2009, 11:34:56 AM

We should make a book of everything that was destroyed, torn down or never built downtown. I would call it ''The Way We Weren't''.

"The Way We Weren't; Or Why Jacksonville History Makes Me Want to Take Anti-Depressants"

Gen7

August 07, 2009, 12:39:56 PM

On a more positive note, since we can't undo our past, The Landing is there and nearly empty of merchants and people.  Since we already have a Farmer's Market on Beaver Street and an Arts Market in Riverside, perhaps something unique would be an International Market at the Landing - Similar to the World of Nations Event that is a big hit every year.  It could feature food, bakery goods, art and music from the various people groups represented in Jacksonville.  I know we have  eastern European, Filipino, Arabic, Jewish, Hispanic, Indian, just to name a few. 

blizz01

August 07, 2009, 01:01:43 PM

Quote
Could a fish market be incorporated into RAM?

I could totally see that first picture in the mezzanine of The Landing every week.  Imagine a flotilla of shrimp boats & fishermen every Saturday docked downtown - incorporated with RAM.  I envision that stretch of Riverwalk in between one day peppered with vendors as well.

Overstreet

August 07, 2009, 01:51:22 PM

Quote
Could a fish market be incorporated into RAM?

I could totally see that first picture in the mezzanine of The Landing every week.  Imagine a flotilla of shrimp boats & fishermen every Saturday docked downtown - incorporated with RAM.  I envision that stretch of Riverwalk in between one day peppered with vendors as well.

More likely the wholesaler bringing them in by truck. Since the shrimp boat docked last night, off loaded and went back out. Fish don't bite  on a Monday- Friday schedule. Then too "Mayport shrimp" might have been caught and off loaded in Brunswick GA.

Gonzo

August 10, 2009, 07:53:16 AM

Here’s a link to the Soulard Farmers Market in St Louis.  We often went there but really did most of our shopping at Schnucks grocery stores.


I grew up in St. Louis myself and remember going to Soulard often as a child. I'd go with my grandparents who lived in south St. Louis. It was always a vibrant, fun experience. And it was located in a historic area of the city near the central part of downtown.

It was part Farmer's Market, part meat market, part outdoor restaurant. There were always vendors hawking wares, colorful sights and heavenly smells. It evokes many fond memories of mornings perusing produce with my grandmother and of my grandfather haggling with the butcher for freash German sausages.

These are the kinds of memories we should be building for our children and the kind of experiences we should be providing the population of our city. They build a greater sense of community and strenghten the ties one has to the city.  As someone who spent 32 years in St. Louis, I still long for "home" even though Jacksonville is my true home now. But, St. Louis has managed to create such a wealth of unique social experiences that it will always hold a place in my heart. This is what Jacksonville needs to create -- a sense of place and community which will rest in visitor's and residents hearts, beconning them to return.

Ocklawaha

August 10, 2009, 10:02:45 AM

Maybe a better point with the Riverside Arts Market is you don't have to build a big expensive building to have a market that people will come to.

A central fish market might be interesting, but I have a fish market less than a mile from my house (excluding the grocery stores). To get to the central retail fish market I'd have to travel twelve miles and pass two other fish markets to get there.  Obviously I'm not the target market for that central fish market.  You need people living nearby.
Then again I'd drive thirty miles to put the boat in and maybe catch a fish. But that is a whole other discussion.

Hate to disagree before I drink my breakfast... "Oh crap, somebody just put juice in my juice bottle!" (W. C. Fields). I would drive from my new perch south of Orangedale. I think you missed a detail here friend Overstreet. A REAL fish market wouldn't just be a place with a freezer or ice chest full of critters. A real fish and farm market would have dozens of wholesaler's haggling with Winn Dixie, Publix and Food Lion officers every morning. Fresh catch of the day could indeed be off loaded on the downtown waterfront. Mix in the exotic, every restaurant in town would be there, some might even be selling fish and chips, fresh oysters, popcorn shrimp and such. This is no little fish department in a big shopping center, this would be big... HUGE. Think of a quay as Disney World for the tastebuds.

OCKLAWAHA

Overstreet

August 10, 2009, 11:41:26 AM

The local fishery could not support that operation.  That location downtown does not lend itself to the logistics of the fish industry in Jacksonville. You'd be forcing it to move there for entertainment not for business.

BridgeTroll

August 10, 2009, 12:46:15 PM

Quote
The local fishery could not support that operation.

That was my thought much earlier in the thread... The shrimping industry is nearly dead... same with Snapper... unless you are gonna sell mullet at the quay there does not seem to be much "local" product available.

blizz01

August 10, 2009, 12:53:17 PM

Crabs.

Fallen Buckeye

August 12, 2009, 06:04:15 PM

I just saw a show about a kind of fish market in the Phillipines where people can buy fresh fish and veggies on side of the market and then once they're done shopping they take the sea food they bought to the other side of the market. There are lots of cooks set up there and you give them the ingredients and tell them how you want them to cook it. Then they cook you a meal and serve it with your ingredients. I wonder if that could work in the U.S. with the health codes and everything, but can you imagine? Have chefs of many different specialties set up on the other side of the market to cook your freshly caught fish or mayport shrimp or crabs. That would be a tourist draw for sure. I don't know the first thing about running a business or I'd set it up myself. lol.
View forum thread
Welcome Guest. You must be logged in to comment on this story.

What are the benefits of having a MetroJacksonville.com account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on stories that interest you.
  • Stay up to date on all of the latest issues affecting your neighborhood.
  • Create a network of friends working towards a better Jacksonville.
» Register now
Already have an account? Login now to comment.