Follow Us

Wednesday, May 22, 2013
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
 

Balboa Park: A Destination, Not A Pass Through

In this new special series, Metro Jacksonville will highlight what several peer cities across the country have created and are implementing to become destinations and not pass throughs. Is Jacksonville ready for the challenge and willing to invest in itself to compete for economic development in the 21st century? The first place we will visit is San Diego's Balboa Park and highlight it's urban Jacksonville counterpart.

Published October 26, 2011 in Learning From      16 Comments    Open printer friendly version of this article Print Article

feature

About Balboa Park



Quote
Balboa Park is a 1,200-acre urban cultural park in San Diego, California. The park is named after the Spanish maritime explorer Vasco Nez de Balboa. It was the location of the 1915 Panama걖California Exposition and 1935 California Pacific International Exposition which each created architectural landmarks for the park.

The park's site was placed in reserve in 1835, and so is one of the oldest sites in the United States dedicated to public recreational use. In addition to open space areas, natural vegetation green belts, gardens and walking paths, it contains a variety of cultural attractions including many museums, several theaters, and the world famous San Diego Zoo. There are also many recreational facilities and several gift shops and restaurants.

Balboa Park, and the historic Exposition buildings, were declared a National Historic Landmark and National Historic Landmark District in 1977, and placed on the National Register of Historic Places. Balboa Park is managed and maintained by the stewardship of the Parks and Recreation Department of the City of San Diego.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balboa_Park_(San_Diego)



Urban Location


Image courtesy of Phil Konstantin at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balboa_Park_(San_Diego)

Set aside for recreation in the 19th century, the urban core of San Diego now completely surrounds this public space, making it possible to enjoy urban living with a cluster of recreational amenities and activities right across the street.

Quote
The park is essentially rectangular in form, bounded by Sixth Avenue to the west, Upas Street to the north, 28th Street to the east, and Russ Boulevard to the south. The rectangle has been modified by the addition of the Marston Hills natural area in the northwest corner of the park, while the southwest corner of the rectangle is occupied by a portion of the Cortez Hill neighborhood of Downtown San Diego and San Diego High School, both of which are separated from the park by Interstate 5. Also encroaching on the northern perimeter of the park is Roosevelt Middle School.

Two north-south canyons - Cabrillo Canyon and Florida Canyon - traverse the park, and separate it into three distinct mesas. The Sixth Avenue Mesa is a narrow strip bordering Sixth Avenue on the western edge of the park, which provides areas of passive recreation, grassy spaces, and tree groves. The Central Mesa is home to much of the park's cultural facilities, and includes scout camps, the San Diego Zoo, the Prado, and Inspiration Point. East Mesa is home to Morley Field and many of the active recreation facilities in the park.

In 1948, California State Route 163 was constructed to run through Cabrillo Canyon and pass under the Cabrillo Bridge. This stretch of road has been called one of America's most beautiful parkways. A portion of Interstate 5 was constructed through the park in the 1950s. In total, freeways take up 111 acres of land that had been initially designated for the park.

Surrounding the park are many of San Diego's older neighborhoods, including Downtown, Bankers Hill, North Park, and Golden Hill.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balboa_Park_(San_Diego)



Pedestrian-friendly neighborhoods adjacent to downtown open up into Balboa Park.


Looking west towards Balboa Park's boundary with the Society Hill neighborhood.


Nate's Point off-leash dog park.


Lawn Bowling.


Passive green space for pick up sports such as soccer and volleyball.


The Cabrillo Bridge, crossing the Cabrillo Canyon, was built for the Panama-California Exposition of 1915.  A popular site for suicides, city workers installed wrought iron fencing on both parapets of the bridge in 1950.


Inside Palm Canyon.


Inside Palm Canyon.


Alcazar Garden, with the California Bell Tower in the background.  The bell tower was completed in 1914 for the Panama-California Exposition of 1915.


Spreckels Organ Pavilion features one of the world's largest outdoor pipe organs.


The Globe Theatre complex.


A rugby team practice near the San Diego Hall of Champions Sports Museum.


A temporary arts market.


A festival at the Hall of Nations.




Despite being such a large park, many choose to walk or bike from nearby neighborhoods.



Park Layout

Quote
The entire Balboa Park is a primary attraction in San Diego and the region. The park's landscape has many mature, and sometimes rare, trees and groves creating an urban forest for San Diego. Many of the original trees were planted by the renowned American landscape designer, botanist, plantswoman, and gardener Kate Sessions. She was a forerunner of using drought tolerant and California native plants in garden design, establishing a nursery to propagate and grow for the park and the public.

Throughout the park there are a number of gardens including: Alcazar Garden, Botanical Building, Desert Cactus Garden, Casa del Rey Moro Garden, Inez Grant Parker Memorial Rose Garden, Japanese Friendship Garden, Bird Park, George W. Marston House and Gardens, Palm Canyon, and Zoro Garden.

Many of the park's cultural attractions are along El Prado, a long, wide promenade and boulevard running through the center of the park. Most of the buildings lining this street are in the Spanish Colonial Revival architecture style, a richly ornamented eclectic mixture of European Spanish architecture and the Spanish Colonial architecture of New Spain-Mexico. Along this boulevard are many of the park's museums and cultural attractions, including the San Diego Museum of Man, the San Diego Museum of Art, the Museum of Photographic Arts, the San Diego Art Institute, the San Diego Model Railroad Museum, the San Diego Natural History Museum, the San Diego History Center, the Reuben H. Fleet Science Center, and the Timken Museum of Art. Other features along El Prado include the Reflection Pond, the latticed Botanical Building, and the Bea Evenson Fountain. Adjacent to the promenade is the San Diego Air & Space Museum.

Theatrical and musical venues include the Spreckels Organ Pavilion, featuring one of the world's largest outdoor pipe organs;[9] the Old Globe Theatre complex, which includes a replica of Shakespeare's Globe Theatre as well as an outdoor stage and a Theatre in the round; and the Starlight Bowl - an outdoor amphitheatre. The Casa Del Prado Theater is the home of San Diego Junior Theatre, the country's oldest children's theatre program. The House of Pacific Relations International Cottages collected on El Prado offer free entertainment shows.

The Botanical Building, a very large lath house, was built in 1915 from a design by Carleton Winslow. The lath house features large specimen palms and other plants inside and is located next to a long reflecting pool on the El Prado side.

Located in the eastern third of the park is the Morley Field Sports Complex. Included in this complex are: the Balboa Park Golf Complex, which contains a public 18-hole golf course and 9-hole executive course; the San Diego Velodrome; baseball and softball fields; the USTA-honored Balboa Tennis Club and tennis courts; archery ranges; the Bud Kearn public swimming pool; and a disc golf course.

Among the institutions and facilities within the park's borders but not administered by the city's Parks Department are the San Diego Zoo, the Naval Medical Center San Diego (NMCSD), and San Diego High School. Other attractions in various areas of the park include chess and bridge outdoor tables, horseshoe pits, playgrounds, walking and jogging trails, sports fields and courts, and picnic areas. Clubs and facilities for petanque and lawn bowling are based in the park.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balboa_Park_(San_Diego)


El Prado




Inside the Sculpture Court Cafe.


The Botanical Building.


Inside the Botanical Building.  Balboa Park contains 350 species of plants on 1,200 acres of rolling hills and canyons, with approximately 1,500 trees.




The San Diego Museum of Art.












Fountain.


Carousel.


Railroad.


Art market.


Natural History Museum.




Casa Del Prado Theater.


Museum of Photographic Arts.





The Future



Quote
Plans are in development for a year-long celebration of the centennial of the 1915-16 exposition, called the Balboa Park 2015 Celebration.

The Balboa Park Conservancy, a non-profit group to preserve and promote the park, was proposed in 2009 and was officially launched on September 14, 2010.

The Park's master plan calls for removing a 67-space parking lot from the Plaza de Panama in front of the San Diego Art Museum, and restoring it as a pedestrian-only plaza. In August 2010 a plan was unveiled by Mayor Jerry Sanders and philanthropist Irwin M. Jacobs to replace that parking with a two-level parking garage at the site of the current Spreckles Organ Pavillion parking lot. The plan also called for making the Cabrillo Bridge one-way, eastbound only, so that people could enter the park via the Cabrillo Bridge but could exit only via Park Boulevard. Instead of the current traffic route through the center of the Prado, inbound traffic would be deflected via a new bridge offramp through the current Alcazar Gardens parking lot toward the new parking garage. The Alcazar Gardens parking lot would be for disabled parking only and for loading and unloading of passengers. The new parking garage would house 750-900 cars and would be landscaped on top. The plan became controversial because of its alteration to the appearance of the bridge and the possibility of charging for parking in the parking garage. In July 2011, the City Council voted to carry out an environmental study on the Jacobs plan and several alternatives.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balboa_Park_(San_Diego)



Jacksonville's Version of Balboa Park: Hogans Creek




Inside The Park

Despite the neglect over the last half century, this public space is still home to many recreational amenities.  

 A. McPherson Park (Gazebo)

 B. Schell Park (Basketball courts)

 C. Klutho Park (Tennis courts)

 D. Klutho Park - "Original Home of Jax Zoo" (Baseball Diamond, Soccer, Bandstand, Fountain)

 E. Confederate Park (Monument to the Women of the Confederacy, Rose Garden)

 F. Springfield Dog Park & Playground





Bordering The Park

What makes this space unlike any other in Jacksonville is the number of historical, medical, educational and cultural establishments immediately adjacent to it.

 1. Shands Jacksonville

 2. VA Clinic

 3. Duval County Health

 4. Former Jacksonville Jewish Center

 5. Historic State Board of Health Building

 6. Bethel Baptist Church

 7. Karpeles Manuscript Museum

 8. Florida State College at Jacksonville Downtown Campus

 9. JEA Waterworks

10. Park View Pavilion/Historic Claude Nolan Cadillac Building

11. Scottish Rite Masonic Temple

12. Old Duval County Armory

13. Old City Cemetary

14. Historic Union Terminal Warehouse Complex

15. Old St. Luke's Hospital (Jacksonville Historic Society Museum & Archives Center)

16. Veteran's Memorial Arena

17. Maxwell House Coffee Plant

18. Shipyards site



Hogans Creek Master Plan.

If Jacksonville desires to be a destination and not a pass through, the structure is in place but it could use a little bit of house cleaning.


Article by Ennis Davis.







Share this article   digg   delicious   reddit   myspace   technorati   google   newsvine  

» 16 Comments

dougskiles

October 26, 2011, 06:45:15 AM
I was thinking Hogans Creek the entire time I read the story.  I'm glad you ended with it.

One common factor in every great park I visit or read about, is the influence/leadership of a non-profit organization.  The greatest thing that could happen to Hogans Creek would the establishment of "Friends of Hogans Creek".  That's not to say that the City government wouldn't be involved, but the motivation, drive and vision would be by the "Friends".

simms3

October 26, 2011, 07:12:59 AM
Very very special place.  Not too many like it in the entire world.  Very few if any urban parks in the country see as many visitors due to all the concentration of significant attractions like the San Diego Zoo, museumS, botanical gardenS, historical featureS, musical venueS, and theaterS, not to mention the Naval Hospital.

I think it's a great study, but I also don't think we'll ever have anything like it at all in Jacksonville or even the entire southeast.

Bativac

October 26, 2011, 07:53:00 AM
My wife and I spent a day in Balboa Park this past summer. It was fantastic. Nothing in Jax even comes close and I have to chuckle at comparing the coffee factory and Shands to the amenities offered at Balboa Park.

Still, Hogans Creek could be fantastic, if time and money were spent fixing the area up. A shame both time and money are in such short supply. Someone with serious vision would almost need to take Hogans Creek on as their pet project and drum up support.

tufsu1

October 26, 2011, 08:11:12 AM
did you check with Mayor Brown on the phrasing of this thread title?

vicupstate

October 26, 2011, 08:15:50 AM
If done right, with the Shipyards and Downtown portions of Hogan's Creek included, the same thing or pretty close to it, could be created in Jax.  But it will take VISION, COMMITMENT and MONEY (public and private) and a decade or two of time to do it.  Changing mayor's every 8 years doesn't help the process either. 

Balboa is indeed remarkable.  San Antonio's Riverwalk should be another selection in this series at some point. Glad to see this series.     

thelakelander

October 26, 2011, 09:12:11 AM
I think it's a great study, but I also don't think we'll ever have anything like it at all in Jacksonville or even the entire southeast.

I'm just making it clear to everyone, that this is not the point of the article.  Balboa Park is just one of many "destinations" in other cities that we'll be highlighting over the next few months.  Although the scale is certainly different, locally Hogans Creek was just as much as a destination to Jaxsons as Balboa Park was to its community during its heyday.  It can be that way again, if we realize it and the surrounding area are an asset, as opposed to a pass through.

Nothing in Jax even comes close and I have to chuckle at comparing the coffee factory and Shands to the amenities offered at Balboa Park.

That was not meant to be a comparison between what exists in Balboa Park and Hogans Creek.  It was meant to show the mix of uses and built-in existing assets in and surrounding Hogans Creek that could be utilized to make it a grand place.  Unlike a Charlotte or an Oklahoma City, we don't have to make these amenities up from scratch. 

did you check with Mayor Brown on the phrasing of this thread title?

No.  However, I do like the phrase and agree with it 100%.  Maybe using it is a subtle way to get the administration to quietly follow this series and perhaps pick up on something that they can work into their plans for making Jax a destination and not a pass through.

thelakelander

October 26, 2011, 09:14:50 AM
By the way, here are a few images of a couple of historic buildings adjacent to Hogans Creek.  Many are completely under utilized but most are in very good shape.  Try finding these in a growing Sunbelt up and comer like Raleigh, Charlotte or Orlando.




From the days when the park had an operating minature golf course.  You can see it in the center of the historic image below.
















Images courtesy of simms3 at http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?t=1190009


Images courtesy of simms3 at http://www.skyscrapercity.com/showthread.php?t=1190009

We have the assets and they happen to already be clustered around an existing green space.  Half our work has already been done for us by previous generations.

Ocklawaha

October 26, 2011, 03:09:13 PM
Damn shame we destroyed the buildings from the old Sub-Tropical Expo, and those of Dixieland Park, but hey we have a really cool oak tree! The buildings in both the Expo and Dixieland were every bit the rivals of Balboa Park. I do wonder how much poo the San Diego Park people clean up at Balboa, sure thing that our park could be as cool, it's just that squish, squish, squish, factor that keeps me turned off.

OCKLAWAHA

John P

October 26, 2011, 05:49:04 PM
This is a project that the Weavers, Haskell etc would all have to be on contribute to. It takes a charasmatic connected leader to start it up.

dougsandiego

October 26, 2011, 11:21:35 PM
Hogans Creek open space is comprised of how many acres?

The buildings you show along the course of the stream are very attractive. I think the mini golf course (re-using the stone gate house) combined with an historic carousel would be a great attraction for families with children.

You should have a a cafe or two; even food trucks (quality local purveyors) with tent canopies next to them to provide shaded dining areas will work.

One very important action which in my opinion should not be delayed: I would notify the community at large that you will host meetings to gather oral histories from long time residents who remember the heyday of Hogan's Creek. Try to determine what they remember about the park; their most positive recollections. If you find many people mentioning the same things, then those features should be at the top of the list for inclusion or restoration during the rehabilitation of the Hogan's Creek area.

Regarding Balboa Park, many of the gardens are completely maintained by volunteers. The Rose Garden for example was conceived and has been maintained since its completion by the San Diego Rose Society.

Many of the attractions in Balboa Park have been in existence since the 1915 and 1935 exhibitions. They seem hokey, but people love them. I speak of the model railway museum,the Children's Theatre, the model train that takes children and their parents on rides "throughout the County of San Diego", The International Cottages which feature natives of foreign lands sharing their music, costumes, food and dance; the Sunday afternoon organ concerts (a regular since 1915), etc.

The carousel , built in the 19th century,and its protective structure was brought to the park from Hotel del Coronado's tent city in the early twentieth century.

These simple attractions along with cafes and gardens make the park a big attraction for all. It is old fashioned  fun. In the evenings people promenade there and take in live theatre. It reminds me of Spain where people take paseos in the evenings. Of course, there is plenty of architecture, which is lit at night,to admire.

I had  to laugh at the comment about cleaning up after the dogs. I think people are pretty good about it. The dog owners have funded all the improvements at Nate's Point.  An aside: The gardener who worked in that area for over 40-years, and after whom Nate's Point is named was interviewed last year on local television. He was asked if he was honored that the dog park had been named after him. His response, "Well, I am a bit confused by that actually, because I was never particularly fond of dogs." The station quickly cut to a commercial. Nate recently died in is 92nd year.

The museums and zoo took much longer to develop, of course. The park has had a long, slow history of development since the King of Spain granted the lands to the Pueblo of San Diego in the late 18th century.

Jacksonville is also an older city with a lot of history. You can and should do your own version of a traditional city park building on the existing assets found in and along Hogan's Creek.

tayana42

October 27, 2011, 12:51:44 AM
Outstanding report.  Thanks for keeping Hogan's Creek in the limelight. 

I-10east

October 27, 2011, 09:03:41 AM
I have a legitimate question; Can the Hogan Creek area even be a 'destination' and not just a pass through? People forget that Hogan Creek is in a flood zone; Not so posh when your upscale restaurant is in two feet of murky water. I'm not trying to be funny, but can the low-lining areas of the Los Angeles River be a 'destination'? I understand that Lake said that he's not comparing Balboa Park, and Hogan Creek; IMO it's unfair to even put them in the same sentence, or thread. Many (not all to the same degree) of the things that Balboa Park has to offer, Jax already has but they are just scattered all over the city like the TU Center for Performing Arts, Cummer Museum, MOSH, Jax Zoo etc, etc; Try to fit all of that into the HC area, good luck. I never been to Cali, and Balboa does look very nice indeed with it's historic buildings, and well maintained greenery, but the major reason for it's success seems to be that it's a very uniquely centralized area with a kabillion museums, the SD Zoo, restaurants etc. True urbanists like many on MJ get a hard on concerning places like Balboa mainly because of so many attractions in a very centralized location. 

thelakelander

October 27, 2011, 09:33:39 AM
^It was a destination a half century ago.  Klutho's flood improvement project even won national awards.  So the precedence has been established.

fieldafm

October 27, 2011, 09:37:08 AM
Quote
This is a project that the Weavers, Haskell etc would all have to be on contribute to. It takes a charasmatic connected leader to start it up

Not even close!  The park system is already there and built out.  All that needs is to be properly maintained. 

The first step is opening up the forgotten area on the Southside of the Matthews Bridge connector.  Connecting the river to the Hogans park system via this area is key IMO. 

You will be seeing how easy this can be soon with identified funding sources. 

Quote
Can the Hogan Creek area even be a 'destination'

Considering it was for over 60 years, yes.

This is Jacksonville's version of Central Park and the existing structure is in place to make this a destination again.  It doesn't have to be as grand in scale as Balboa Park or NYC's Central Park, but it can be better utilized which in turn will open access to the river and be a vital link b/w the Downtown Core, Springfield, the Cathedral District and the Sports District.

I-10east

October 27, 2011, 10:48:07 AM
I don't think that the Hogan Creek park area will ever become anything like it once was in the past. Over the years from it's glory days, that area has become blue collar, and low income (I'm not saying that it's anything wrong with that BTW) with nearby Jacksonville Housing Authority(JHA) housing like the Centennial Townhouses West, the Hogan Creek Tower, and the Blodgett Homes(now Blodgett Villas) The Blodgett Villas are WAY better than the old Blodgett Homes which was probably the worst apartments in Jax during the 80's. Hell even JHA's 1300 Bldg is there. I do agree that the HC area is under ultilized. I do hope that the area will reach it's potential, but places like Balboa, SA's Riverwalk etc. are on a different stratosphere. All I can hope for there is the cleaning of Hogan Creek, sidewalk repair, better lawn care, masonry refurbishment, and small scale things of that nature. Maybe with a prayer or two, a hot dog truck, and recreational activity taking place. :) 

Ocklawaha

October 27, 2011, 01:04:40 PM
I had  to laugh at the comment about cleaning up after the dogs. I think people are pretty good about it. The dog owners have funded all the improvements at Nate's Point.  An aside: The gardener who worked in that area for over 40-years, and after whom Nate's Point is named was interviewed last year on local television. He was asked if he was honored that the dog park had been named after him. His response, "Well, I am a bit confused by that actually, because I was never particularly fond of dogs." The station quickly cut to a commercial. Nate recently died in is 92nd year.

Sorry I misled you in that comment, I was actually trying to be kind, but the poo is human... It's a Long Way to Tipperary!

OCKLAWAHA
View forum thread
Welcome Guest. You must be logged in to comment on this story.

What are the benefits of having a MetroJacksonville.com account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on stories that interest you.
  • Stay up to date on all of the latest issues affecting your neighborhood.
  • Create a network of friends working towards a better Jacksonville.
Register now
Already have an account? Login now to comment.