I keep hearing conflicting information about the Jail - are we truly hitting a capacity or facility end of life (downtown revitalization aside)?
The jail/PDF is technically supposed to house around 2,200 inmates. I think we average closer to 3,000, peaking at like 3,500 in the early stages of COVID when we couldn't transfer prisoners easily between the PDF and state prisons. Not sure how that compares to other metros though, and whether the solution would be to build an entire replacement, or just find somewhere else to house the overflow (or, obviously, work harder on the real root of the issue).
In terms of end-of-life, the facility is only around 30 years old. We just put about $1 million into making it ADA compliant, and we also just replaced the entire HVAC system serving the prison.
Kinda feels like the same people saying that the jail is in desperate need of replacement are the same people saying that JEA would go into freefall if we didn't urgently explore privatization, or that the Hart Bridge ramps were badly impeding logistics into Talleyrand and needed to be removed, or that the Landing was holding back downtown development, etc.
One thing's for certain is that we need to make our downtown plans with the assumption that the jail is going to be there for at least another 8-10 years, minimum. It took SIXTEEN YEARS to study, plan, and build the existing facility. We're not going to snap our fingers, start construction of a half-billion dollar prison elsewhere next year, and be ready to move inmates and demolish the old prison by the time the Four Seasons opens. It's just not realistic.
Which is why it's frustrating to hear people casually putting plans for things like a convention center on hold pending the moving of the prison. One doesn't simply move a 3,000 inmate prison overnight. Logistically, it's probably the most complex project we could undertake as a city. And we haven't even explored it yet formally. Totally get the "move the jail" crowd, even though I disagree with it, but at this point in time, it's about as realistic a suggestion as moving the Main Street Bridge.