I understand both sides. Sometimes old articles are bumped (last or second to last post requoted) with no new addition or visible reason. Then I click on it and it is nothing new. Other times, as in this case, something is added onto, and the same debate that took place weeks/months/years ago happens all over again. And those can be frustrating to older readers.
But I think the people that run this site (the only ones I know are Lakelander and Stephendare, apologies to any others) doing a great job and content like this you cannot find anywhere else. Not even trendy, liberal, edgy New York City!