Of course that discounts the fact that the only reason there is a red snapper fishery in the Gulf near the state of Florida is the artifical reef program founded by fishermen and divers that provides habitat for red snapper, grouper and other fishes. This has drastically increased the red snapper populations. You could read Dr Bob Shipp and learn more, but you ignore all of that.
Your experts are some Californians at the Monteray Aquarium. An aquarium more interested in kelp beds.
You didn't notice that I just posted an article that says just that,...........that the fishermen in the Gulf Coast have been very actively promoting sustainable fishing! Their only complaint is regarding the sportsmen not being held accountable:
The alliance is also striving to bring some form of accountability to the recreational fleet that claims 49 percent of the overall red snapper quota in the Gulf of Mexico. As of now, there is no tagging program and no reporting requirement.