Thursday, August 28thAdvertising  |  About Us  |  Contact Us
Duval County Courthouse: Examples of What Money Can Buy Print E-mail
Wednesday, 27 December 2006

Above Image: An illustration of Calgary, AB's $280 million two block courthouse complex, currently under construction.

The City of Jacksonville has recently selected the design-build firm, Auchter/Perry McCall to design the first phase of the long delayed Duval County Courthouse project. The first phase will include a 388,000 square foot, criminal courts structure, estimated to cost $140 million. Construction is anticipated to begin in the fall of 2007. Lets hope that the team of Auchter/Perry McCall has enough design skill and talent to come up with a master site plan and courthouse layout that works for both the courthouse complex and downtown's redevelopment. In the spirit of getting rid of the CBD's largest crater, the following courthouse projects are examples of what type of county courthouse buildings money can buy in the era of rapidly rising construction prices.

 Phoenix Municipal Courthouse – Phoenix, AZ

Gross Floor Area: 375,000 square feet; 10 stories; 161 feet tall)

Construction Costs: $77,800,000

Completion Date: 1999

Architect of Record: Daniel, Manning, Johnson and Mendenhall

The Phoenix Municipal Courthouse was opened to the public on December 27, 1999. It was designed and constructed to provide attractive, comfortable, efficient space with the flexibility to meet the city's future criminal justice needs. The Courthouse houses 590 employees who work in the Municipal Court, Prosecutor's Office, Public Defender and Police Department.

The construction of the new courthouse was authorized by the City Council in December 1995, with a fall 1999 completion date. In conjunction with the construction of the courthouse, the project included the structural and exterior renovation of the historic Walker Building on the same site. The total project budget of approximately $77.8 million was funded with city of Phoenix Civic Improvement Corporation Excise Tax Revenue Bonds and 1988 Historic Preservation General Obligation Bonds.

An estimated $900,000 in construction costs were avoided by connecting the courthouse to the City's underground chiller system that now serves 6 downtown buildings. An estimated $90,000 in annual electricity costs were also saved by this approach to cooling.

 

 

 

Scott M. Matheson Courthouse – Salt Lake City

Gross Floor Area: 420,000 square feet; 7 stories

Construction Costs: $115,500,000

Completion Date: 2005

Architect of Record: HOK

This seven story structure houses 37 courtrooms, a four-story glass rotunda, a two-story common gallery area, and is one of the largest public buildings in the State of Utah.

 

 

 

Clark County Regional Justice Center – Las Vegas, NV

Gross Floor Area: 700,000 square feet; 18 stories

Construction Costs: $185,000,000 (originally estimated to cost $120,000,000).

Completion Date: 2004

Architect of Record: Tate Snyder Kimsey Architects

The Regional Justice Center contains 700,000 square feet of space to house four different court systems: Municipal, Justice, District, and Supreme. The eighteen-story concrete structure is surrounded by a five-story volume to help make the scale more context friendly. A light-filled, canyon-like space runs through this volume and terminates at the main entrance, which is elevated and features a civic plaza that reflects traditional courthouse design. Unfortunately, the RJC has been plagued by construction problems. This building won an AIA Nevada Design Award in 1999.

 

 

 

Harris County Civil Justice Center – Houston, TX (right)

Gross Floor Area: 660,000 square feet; 18 stories (378 feet)

Construction Costs: $115,500,000

Completion Date: 2005

Architect of Record: Pierce Goodwin Alexander & Linville

This recently completed 18 story structure includes 37 typical courtrooms, 1 tax courtroonm, 1 ceremonial courtroom and 6 expansion courtrooms, in addition to the District Clerk, County Clerk and Court Administration Offices.

Harris County Criminal Justice Center – Houston, TX (left)

Gross Floor Area: 20 stories

Construction Costs: $95,000,000

Completion Date: 2001

Architect of Record: Pierce Goodwin Alexander and Linville

This 20 story structure is the largest of Houston’s "Courthouse Square" project, which is an attempt to relieve overcrowding at the area’s current facilities, caused by a rapidly increasing population.

Total construction costs for Civil and Criminal Courthouse Towers: $210,500,000

 

 

 

Calgary Courthouse – Calgary, AB

Gross Floor Area: 1,200,000 Square feet

Construction Costs: $280 million

Completion Date: 2006

The Project is a competition-winning design for a $280 million development which will be the largest consolidated Judicial complex in North America. Two towers flank a soaring 30-story atrium to create a landmark building for the Provincial Court, Court of Queens Bench and the Court of Appeal. This multi-level complex includes 90 Courts, extensive Judicial Chambers, rehabilitation of an existing heritage building and the creation of new urban park. NORR is working in association with Carlos Ott, Design Consultant Architect of Record for this project is Kasian Kennedy Architects.


















 
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Latest Features

Latest News

Related Articles

Duval County Courthouse: Still stumbling in the Dark
$350 million finally approved, a third design team hired and four years later, the questions raised in this letter to our city officials still remain...
Free Bird Live Downtown, Why not?
Free Bird needs a new location and downtown advocates want more nightlife. Can a match be made?  
Large Venues and Small Business: Why Government makes it Impossible to Coexist
Over the last 15 years, nearly a billion dollars has been poured into our downtown sports complex, and city leaders have been very quick...
>> 9 Comments
southernboi
December 27, 2006, 9:52 am


While I do understand the need to go vertical I don't like the super tall buildings for the court house. They look like offices or condos, not a court house. The original design, (exterior), was beautiful, stately, and really said court house. I know a lot has been bemoaned about it and the cost. Architecturally speaking Jacksonville has nothing in the down town like it. The majority of the jewels of DT have been destroyed. We need something like that design. I hope the new architects will design something similar.
Jason
December 27, 2006, 9:54 am


I like the Calgary and Salt Lake courthouses.  Personally, I think a more traditional design would look better.  
JJ
December 27, 2006, 9:58 am
Great idea

I think it is a great idea. I like the ones in Las Vegas and Salt Lake City. I personally think the Phoenix one is hideous.
FD
December 29, 2006, 3:41 pm
Why Traditional?

I don't understand why a courthouse has to look like or say court house.  The building should be designed in a way that best allows it to actually function as a court house regardless of whether it looks like a court house, an office buildint, a condo, or whatever.  Sure, it should add to downtown's architecture but a early 20th century version of a courthouse isn't what we need.  Go high, save space, save money.
Jerome Howard
January 19, 2007, 5:49 pm
Houston's criminal justice center

I definately like Houston's criminal justice center's design. We do need to follow that example to keep the cost down.
Lunican
December 2, 2007, 12:55 pm
Re: Duval County Courthouse: Examples of What Money Can Buy

Considering Jacksonville's courthouse is now expected to cost $400 million, we better start looking at alternatives.
Ocklawaha
December 2, 2007, 4:26 pm
Re: Duval County Courthouse: Examples of What Money Can Buy

I love the hi-rise idea, I wish our city would think "up" more often. I also have a hunch that when a new hi-rise is on the build, it tends to attract more follow-on projects then a low building. Maybe Lake can weigh in on this. While I love history and tradition, I think our plan looks way to "Mayberry" for a WILD CARD...SUPER BOWL champion City!


Orlando, Florida................  Miami, Florida...............Los Angeles (concept)

Ocklawaha
thelakelander
December 2, 2007, 8:22 pm
Re: Duval County Courthouse: Examples of What Money Can Buy

Quote
I also have a hunch that when a new hi-rise is on the build, it tends to attract more follow-on projects then a low building. Maybe Lake can weigh in on this.

I don't have any stats, but you would have the possibility of more development in a compact area, because a low rise building would be spread out, sucking up the potential for major new complementing development coming in nearby.  Personally, I think they need to go back to last year's Rink concept, that called for a building that was going to be 15 stories tall.  That structure was going to take up two blocks instead of four and it was cheaper too.  The thing being paraded around is the worst design yet, but it costs two kidneys instead of one.
raheem942
December 6, 2007, 11:37 am
Re: Duval County Courthouse: Examples of What Money Can Buy

bigger is better babby i say do it
Welcome Guest. You must be logged in to comment on this story.

What are the benefits of having a MetroJacksonville.com account?
  • Share your opinion by posting comments on stories that interest you.
  • Stay up to date on all of the latest issues affecting your neighborhood.
  • Create a network of friends working towards a better Jacksonville.
>> Register now <<
Already have an account? Login now to comment.